Thank you all for the kind words.
Having both side by side I think I would choose my brothers Redeemer. Man that thing turned out nice. I'm not saying the Prodigal Son isn't nice. I love what it is as an iconic piece of art. But aesthetically speaking the Redeemer just looks amazing in person and it feels solid. The PS for me was mainly for shelf not slay purposes but it does look great as well and I do love it.
There is a bit of a rattle coming from the LED module shifting in the bore of the grenade section (the snap ring is seated properly) when I swing the PS around with or without the blade in it. The Redeemer on the other hand has no rattles and it also sounds louder. Both have great colour. The 12w+ in the Green and Light Blue really look great. Both have 32" blades. Took 8 weeks exactly from the day of order off Etsy to receive them in Canada.